Kitchener-Waterloo

Cambridge to remove bollards which cost $130K and 'never quite worked'

The four electrically-operated bollards on Dickson Street began to malfunction soon after they were installed almost a decade ago. The issue was eventually taken to court.

City held back payment for the bollards when staff realized the bollards were faulty

Cambridge city hall.
A set of faulty retractable bollards are being removed only a decade after installation on Dickson Street in Cambridge. (Kate Bueckert/CBC)

The city of Cambridge has decided to remove a set of retractable bollards that ended up becoming more of a nuisance for city staff rather than a safety measure.

The four electrically-operated barriers on Dickson Street began to malfunction soon after they were installed almost a decade ago. The were installed to help block off car access to certain streets that would be open to pedestrians only during special events. The bollards, which were meant to come out of the ground with a simple touch of a button, were supposed to make it easier for staff to set up for events.

But the city's goal to more efficiently prepare for community events remained out of reach.

"They never quite worked satisfactorily," said Hardy Bromberg, Cambridge's deputy city manager for community development.

"Maybe only three quarters of [the bollards] would would rise and another day, only two of them. Sometimes all eight [would rise] and sometimes not at all. That was a real problem."

Silver squares in the ground.
Silver squares embedded in the road on Dickson Street in Cambridge are retractable bollards. They will rise out of the ground when the city needs to block off traffic for events. (Google Maps)

Bromberg says that's why the city decided not pay for the bollards, which cost $130,000 The issue was taken to court and there was a legal settlement in 2021 with Service Door Industries, the manufacturer of the bollards, and Nex Industrial, the supplier.

Bromberg says the cost to remove the bollards and repave the road will come from the city's capital fund, and was not included in the settlement. He estimates removal will cost the city approximately $20,000.

He says the city will be using portable barricades instead of the retractable bollards to block traffic during future events.

Bromberg says the bollards should be gone by early fall.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Aastha Shetty

CBC journalist

Aastha Shetty can be reached via email [email protected]