Toronto's threat of tax hike in absence of federal shelter money a 'shakedown,' Liberal MP says
City says additional 6% take hike necessary without $250M in federal support
A Toronto Liberal MP says the city is trying to "shakedown" the federal government with its warning that property taxes could go up by 16.5 per cent if Ottawa doesn't come through with more funding for sheltering asylum seekers.
"I find it incredibly disappointing, I find it outrageous," said MP Yvan Baker, who represents Etobicoke Centre, in an interview with CBC Radio's Metro Morning on Wednesday.
"We've provided funding for not just COVID, but for housing, for asylum seekers, for transit to the tune of billions of dollars per year. This year it will be close to $3 billion."
Baker's comments are the latest volley in a public war of words between Toronto Mayor Olivia Chow's budget committee and local Liberal MPs.
The tensions come after city staff released their proposed fiscal plan for 2024, which recommended a total of 10.5 per cent in tax increases for property owners — the single-biggest annual increase since amalgamation in 1998 — as they try to fill a $1.8 billion budget shortfall.
But budget chief Coun. Shelley Carroll also said if the federal government doesn't provide $250 million for Toronto's straining shelter system, the city will "have no choice" but to impose an additional six per cent "Federal Impacts Levy."
Carroll said revenue from the novel tax would be needed to shelter the 5,800 asylum seekers and refugee claimants who currently account for more than half of the city's shelter capacity. Carroll told reporters this week that the influx is a result of "federal actions and federal policy" and the costs should be "squarely the responsibility of the federal government."
The Toronto Star reported Tuesday that at least some of Toronto's 25 Liberal MPs are furious Chow and her closest council allies are trying to pin a potential tax hike on the federal government.
Mayor 'misleading' taxpayers, MP says
Baker said Wednesday that sheltering asylum seekers and refugee claimants has always been a "shared responsibility" and he accused Chow of "misleading the people of Toronto."
"Olivia Chow needs to start telling the truth to the citizens of Toronto about the degree to which the federal government has stepped up," Baker said, pointing to the nearly $5.5 billion the Liberal government has sent to the city since it took office. That includes $97 million last summer specifically for the shelter system.
Baker went on to allege that the city has not been transparent enough about the true costs associated with its shelters.
"To me, this feels a little bit like a shakedown," Baker said. "I can't support funding going to another level of government, for any initiative for that matter, if I don't have confidence that that funding is going to the cause it's supposed to be going to, that it's the right amount of money, and that it's actually going to help solve the problem."
In a statement posted to X, formerly Twitter, Chow said she's optimistic more federal money will flow.
"Funding and support for refugees is a gap in our budget so we need to address it. All along I've said we have a great partnership and I know the Federal Government and Toronto MPs want to come through for Torontonians, like they have before."
Speaking to Metro Morning last week, Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Marc Miller said his staff have been at the table with the city. While he couldn't guarantee anything, Miller said he sees "something positive coming on the horizon."
City wants sustained funding: councillor
Toronto city staff project that as many as 10,000 asylum seekers and refugees could be seeking shelter by the end of 2024. Toronto currently has roughly 9,000 total shelter beds, with some capacity added during the winter months.
Coun. Gord Perks, a member of Chow's budget committee, said that while $250 million is the estimated cost associated with asylum seekers and refugees this year, the city doesn't want just a "one-time cheque" from Ottawa.
"It is not the responsibility of the people of Toronto to pay for asylum seekers, immigration and people seeking refuge. Nobody has ever believed that," Perks said.
"We want the federal government to take on responsibility for people who are arriving in this country, seeking refuge, so that they can live their best lives here and so they don't wind up on a sidewalk. It's not a complicated thing."
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
With files from CBC Radio's Metro Morning and Shawn Jeffords