Saskatoon

Point of View | 'If the scar is deep, so was the love': Dealing with my first Father's Day without Papa

A new bond formed between my father and I as he drew his last breaths last August.

It's a feeling shared by everyone whose dad is a 'was'

Courtney Markewich (right) with her father, Charlie Mintenko, who died in August 2018 shortly after a diagnoses of Stage IV lung cancer. (Kyle Markewich)

A new bond formed between my father and I as he drew his last breaths last August.

I think I was about six years old when I first understood what death was and that my dad had parents who I had never met.

I remember how sad I was to realize that I had grandparents who died before I was born. I also remember how my dad responded to my sadness, sharing stories with me of his parents as he tucked me in at night.

Bedtime was one of the first ways I became a daddy's girl. My dad was a master at tuck ins. He taught me how to make shadow puppets with my nightlight and read me The Monster at the End of this Book too many times to count.

It was the stories he told about his parents that really taught me his character.

Dad — who we lovingly called Papa Bear — always told me happy stories about growing up on a farm near Russell, Man. As I grew older I learned his childhood wasn't always the happy affair he shared from my bedside. 

My childhood was full of the love and smiles that weren't always there during his. Someday, when I tuck in my own children, I will get to tell them stories about their grandfather the way he did for me. 

A musical connection

Papa and I shared a great bond over music. 

It's always been a joke in my family that I — a late addition to the family, 10 years younger than my nearest sibling — had to come along so Dad had someone to share his music with.

My sister would sing along, but I was the child who ended up picking up the guitar and learning to play.

Dad got me to learn the bass instead — he needed a bass player in his band — and the drums for a while, too. 

Markewich started singing with her dad at a young age. Some of their first performances together were at church talent shows. (Supplied by Courtney Markewich)

What started as jams in the basement ended up on stages across Saskatchewan. I started to play with Papa in a polka band when I was 15. It was a nice way to make some extra money on the weekends, but the best part was spending time with Papa. 

We jammed for the last time, back in the basement where it had first begun, about three weeks before Papa died. 
I didn't want to believe it would be our last time playing together, but I knew I had to soak it in. We only played for about 90 minutes that day — pretty short compared to the four-hour dances we used to play — but for that hour-and-a-half we forgot about the cancer destroying his body. 

'If the scar is deep, so was the love'

I turned to online articles a lot in the first weeks after losing Papa. One line, found in a Reddit post, really resonated with me.

"If the scar is deep, so was the love."

While that line has brought me comfort, I've also realized that my "scar" hasn't fully formed yet. It's still a healing cut, irritated at times. Even though I have countless memories of the amazing man my dad was, the bad memories of his illness and our loss can flood my mind. 

Courtney Markewich's wedding in July 2014 did have a traditional father/daughter dance, but it was also very important to her that they sang together. (Lori Trost Photography)

This Father's Day is going to suck. There will be tears, anger and loneliness.

I know I'm not alone. It's not just me and my family. It's a feeling shared by everyone whose dad is a "was."

This Father's Day, as I start to sink into the sadness of wishing I could feel one more hug from Papa, I know I'll be able to stop, close my eyes and feel his love.

It's still there. It always will be.


This column is part of CBC's Opinion section. For more information about this section, please read this editor's blog and our FAQ.

Interested in writing for us? We accept pitches for opinion and point-of-view pieces from Saskatchewan residents who want to share their thoughts on the news of the day, issues affecting their community or who have a compelling personal story to share. No need to be a professional writer! Email [email protected] with your idea.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Courtney Markewich joined CBC News in 2016 after working in radio for five years. She is based in Saskatoon. Born and raised in Saskatchewan, Markewich is passionate about sharing stories of the province's people. Her focus now is bringing these stories to social media on CBC Saskatchewan and CBC Saskatoon's platforms. Her work on The Pit was recognized by the RTDNA Canada National Awards for Excellence in Social Media in 2020. You can contact her at [email protected].