New Brunswick

Love letters and sweetheart pins: The romantic side of military history

With Valentine's Day on the horizon, love is in the air, and David Hughes from the New Brunswick Military History Museum says there's a romantic side to military history.

'I can never be happy again until we are together,' love letter from New Brunswick soldier says

A black and white photo of a woman, left, and a man, right, smiling and looking at each other.
In a love letter to his sweetheart Selma, left, who was in Amsterdam at the time, gunner Sidney Smith, right, wrote of his undying love for Selma and how he couldn't wait for her to come to Canada. Pictured is a wedding photo of the couple. (Submitted by New Brunswick Military History Museum)

Before there were stuffed bears holding chocolate boxes, there were more personal expressions of love in the handwritten letters and small trinkets given to sweethearts, a common practice among soldiers.

"I would rather die then to have anything happen between us," said a 1946 letter, sent from New Brunswick to Amsterdam.

"I am looking for the day when there will be a telegram for me saying you are on your way to Canada for I can never be happy again until we are together even if it had to be 100 years from now."

Those lines are from a letter sent 78 years ago by a Second World War gunner from New Brunswick to his Dutch war bride.

Sidney Smith, from Moores Mills, near St. Stephen, wrote to his sweetheart Selma in Amsterdam right before he was demobilized from the military, said David Hughes, manager of the New Brunswick Military History Museum.

A silver, red and blue pin with a 236 on the bottom.
This sweetheart pin is from the 236th Battalion, the MacLean Kilties, a New Brunswick unit from the First World War. (Michael Heenan/CBC)

The letter expressed Smith's loneliness and longing as he went to bed alone each night, wishing Selma could be with him.

Another letter from that same year talked about a recent purchase of a brand new $30 mattress and box spring for the two to one day sleep on together.

"It was worth it," he wrote of the price. "I don't like to buy very much until you are here for I want to get things that you want."

WATCH | ​Jewelry for soldiers' sweethearts:

Sweetheart pins: Soldiers' gifts of love

11 hours ago
Duration 4:41
​David Hughes, manager of the New Brunswick Military History Museum at CFB Gagetown, explains the tradition of military sweetheart pins and showcases several from the museum's collection. ​

Hughes said such romantic gestures were common in military romances, including in the form of what were known as sweetheart pins.

"Sweetheart pins were, and still are, gifts that are traditionally given from a soldier to his wife or sweetheart," said Hughes.

"They're generally miniature versions of the soldier's unit badge or shoulder title or some other kind of military identifier, usually done in miniature, often times done in gold or silver, sometimes decorated with enamel to make it more colourful.

A shadow box of different pins
A box of sweetheart pins showing their different variety. In the top right corner of the box, there is the pin and dog tags that Hughes gave to his own sweetheart. (Vanessa Vander Valk/CBC)

"It's just a symbol of affection and belonging … from the soldier to his sweetheart."

In Canada, Hughes said these were most common during the First World War, but they were also given during the Second World War and even in modern day.

Hughes said he gave a silver miniature of the Royal Canadian Regiment cap badge to his sweetheart, as well as a set of gold dog tags he had made when he was on a peacekeeping mission in Cyprus. 

"It was a big moment for me," he said. "Hopefully my sweetheart thought so as well."

As for Sydney Smith and the woman he was pining for, Selma later came to Canada where the couple lived a happy life together. 

"I love you so much dear every time I think of you it nearly makes me cry."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Hannah Rudderham is a reporter with CBC New Brunswick. She grew up in Cape Breton, N.S., and moved to Fredericton in 2018. You can send story tips to [email protected].

With files from Shift

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Get the latest top stories from across New Brunswick in your inbox every weekday.

...

The next issue of CBC New Brunswick newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.