London

Hobbyists revisit the last time Canada had its 'elbows up' against U.S. annexation

Hobbyists re-enacting a 211-year-old War of 1812 battle nearLondon, Ont., say a lot can be learned from the last time Canada had its 'elbows up' against American annexation.

The War of 1812 saw American troops march on Canada in a failed annexation attempt

People dressed as British infantry march with muskets on a dirt road
Hobbyists in scarlet uniforms and stovepipe hats practice drills at the Longwoods Conservation Area in Delaware, Ont., as part of the 211th anniversary of the battle of Longwoods, a skirmish between American raiders and British regulars in the War of 1812. (Colin Butler/CBC News)

Each year near London, Ont., a group of people from Canada and the United States gather to recreate a war so many Canadians and Americans rarely think about outside of a history class. 

The War of 1812 raged for three years between Great Britain and the U.S., and saw hostile American troops cross the border into Canada as part of a failed invasion meant to make the fledgling colony of Upper Canada America's newest state. 

The Battle of Longwoods, fought near the end of the war, in early March of 1814, saw the British and their Canadian and Indigenous allies clash with U.S. forces near Delaware, Ont., as part of an ongoing series of raids in which American troops burned and pillaged Canadian farms and homesteads across southwestern Ontario. 

In his 1980 book, the Invasion of Canada 1812-1813, Pierre Berton called the conflict "a foolish war that scarcely anyone wanted or needed, but which, once launched, no one knew how to stop." 

A man in a period British military tunic and floppy hat
Chris McKay, of London, Ont., poses in his period uniform outside a command tent at the Longwoods Conservation Area in Delware, at the annual recreation of the Battle of Longwoods. (Colin Butler/CBC News)

In present day Delaware, hobbyists from both camps can't help but see parallels between the conflict they're trying to recreate and the current trade war between Canada and the U.S.

'There's suffering on all sides'

"There's suffering on all sides," Chris McKay, a re-enactor who has been participating in the hobby for the past 20 years told Ismaila Alfa on CBC Radio's Fresh Air on Saturday.

"It's experiential history. You're really understanding what they went through," he said, noting re-enactors wear period woolen clothing, sleep outdoors in canvas tents and cook meals on a campfire just like they did 211 years ago. 

As Canada navigates renewed trade tensions with the U.S., we look back at a time when the two countries were at war. Chris McKay, a longtime re-enactor with the Upper Thames Military Re-enactment Society, joins Ismaila Alfa to reflect on the Battle of the Longwoods, what it teaches us about resilience, and what keeps him coming back 20 years later.

"When you're putting on all the equipment, you know what it feels like to carry that weight and carry around that 10 or 12 pound musket all day." 

Asked what he thought of U.S. President Donald Trump's recent comments about making Canada the 51st state, McKay said the remarks have been discussed at length by hobbyists on both sides of the border. 

"I know a lot of people felt a lot of anger. For me, it was a lot of disappointment," McKay said. "As re-enactors we sat down and said, 'let's not forget who our friends are.'"

Co-operation, friendship endure despite conflict

The same might have been said during the War of 1812, which saw communities on both sides of the border continue to trade and even engage in some remarkable acts of co-operation, such as the legend about the people of Calais, Maine borrowing a keg of gunpowder from the Canadians in St. Stephen, N.B., despite the war. 

A kettle on a fire near a tent with actors dressed as soldiers
A kettle comes to a boil over an open fire near Delaware, Ont., as War of 1812 re-enactors in period military dress from Canada and the U.S. recreate the 1814 Battle of Longwoods on its 211th anniversary. (Colin Butler/CBC News)

McKay said Canada's shared border with the U.S., the longest undefended frontier on Earth, and the last 200 years of peace are both products of the conflict. 

"That grew out of the War of 1812, that relationship grew out of the early 19th century and we've worked really hard and built that and I was really disappointed to have that thrown away so quickly [by Donald Trump]." 

On the other side of the park, in the American encampment, Martin Land, from Toledo, Ohio, dressed in the dark blue tunic of an American commander from the period reclines on a wooden chair.

He said he has been coming to re-enact this battle for the past 25 years and believes that one American president can't undo a bilateral relationship that's been the envy of the world now for centuries. 

A man in navy blue period dress from the American military
Martin Land, of Toledo, Ohio, has been coming to recreate the Battle of Longwoods for the past 25 years as a War of 1812 re-enactor. He said the current tension over trade between Canada and the U.S. 'baffles' him. (Colin Butler/CBC News)

"I believe that to be the case," said Land. "I didn't vote for him."

"It's one big economy in many ways. There's no point in stirring up trouble. I'm baffled," he said, noting that politics aside, the cross border friendships will endure.

"People don't change that easy." 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Colin Butler

Reporter

Colin Butler is a veteran journalist with 20 years' experience in print, radio and television in seven Canadian cities. You can email him at [email protected].