Hamilton

Why Stanley Cup champ Dan Carcillo blames hockey culture for hazing assaults: Matt Cullen

After disturbing allegations of assault and sexual assault against students at St. Michael's College School, a few athletes have spoken out about their experience with hazing. That includes former NHLer Daniel Carcillo. CBC Sports' Matt Cullen spoke with Carcillo about hazing in the OHL.

'You have these men in power who, if you question anything, will threaten your path to your dream'

Daniel Carcillo (13) celebrates after scoring a goal for the Chicago Blackhawks during a game against the Buffalo Sabres in 2014. He won two Stanley Cups with Chicago. (Nam Y. Huh/Associated Press)

After disturbing allegations of assault and sexual assault against students at St. Michael's College School, a few athletes have spoken out about their experience with hazing. That includes former NHLer Daniel Carcillo. CBC Sports' Matt Cullen spoke with Carcillo about hazing in the OHL.

Following the disturbing allegations at St. Michael's College School of assault and sexual assault against student athletes by their teammates, a few athletes have been coming forward to talk about their experiences with hazing.

Earlier this week, former NHLer Daniel Carcillo, a two-time Stanley Cup winner with the Chicago Blackhawks, revealed that, as a rookie with the OHL's Sarnia Sting in 2002, he too was abused by teammates.

He told the CBC that "One of the most vivid memories that stands out is one of my teammates being taped to a table ass-up naked being whipped with his own belt by two veterans. He was screaming."

He said one of the coaches heard the screams and came out of his office. He said the coach gave the player who was tied down a token slap.

Matt Cullen, a reporter for CBC Sports, also provides commentary for the OHL's Mississauga Steelheads, spoke with the CBC's Conrad Collaco about Carcillo and the hockey culture that allows hazing to exist. 

You can read an abridged and edited version of the interview or listen to the full audio interview by hitting the play button above.

Matt Cullen, CBC Sports 

Matt Cullen is a reporter for CBC Sports and is also a play-by-play commentator for the OHL's Mississauga Steelheads. (CBC Sports)

Matt, you had a chance to speak with Daniel Carcillo earlier this week, what did he say about his time in the Ontario Hockey League?

First of all he said that he hated hockey culture — past hockey culture and current hockey culture. Fans of the OHL and NHL will remember Carcillo as an agitator, as a fighter. He played a very aggressive style. He played 429 NHL games and had more than 1,200 penalty minutes. He said that coming out of the OHL he was an angry, confused kid. That was because of the abuse he suffered when he played for the Sarnia Sting. He said that experience shaped the way he played the game. Hockey was his escape, his emotional release. He vented his anger on the ice.

He's retired now, doing a lot of advocacy work. He says there's a lot he hasn't reconciled yet. He says there were about 11 or 12 players that took abuse every single day in the dressing room, in the shower, on the bus. At the time, as a 16-year-old or 17-year-old, he didn't know how to deal with the trauma and how deep it was inside him. He says that hockey culture is the reason why. The story has picked up a lot of traction. His ex-teammates are coming out and all of them say the scars are still there.

Former NH L player and two-time Stanley Cup champ Daniel Carcillo talks about why he hates hockey culture.
I hate... I just can't stand hockey culture. You have these men in power who, if you question anything, will threaten your path to your dream.- Daniel Carcillo, former NHL and OHL player

Millions of Canadian kids grow up playing hockey or other competitive sports where hazing is a past or current tradition. As we saw in the case at St. Michael's College School, many of the victims don't tell their parents. How should parents approach these situations?

It's a very difficult situation for everyone. Carcillo says players should talk about it. He went directly to the OHL and CHL commissioner David Branch. Carcillo says the OHL has left some ex-teammates in a bad spot but says he believes that the OHL and Branch did a lot to help and change that situation. He says Branch was legitimately concerned about his well-being. At the time he was getting in to some suspension trouble. He says the hockey culture did improve.

As for parents, it's very difficult to do something if you don't know about it. A lot of these players live with billet families far away from their homes. He says it's very difficult for everyone to try and deal with this situation. 

That's hockey culture. Parents need to be mindful of that. When you're a young player — you're trying to get more time on the ice, trying to move into the next level, perhaps move into the NHL — the last thing you want to do is rock the boat, make it difficult for coaches to play you, or make your situation worse than it already is. 

I don't blame my parents. For a long time it was hard. It was so hard to tell them. You don't want to tell them because then they're going to come and get you and then your dream is over.- Daniel Carcillo, former NHL and OHL player
Daniel, Carcillo, Ontario hockey league, hockey, hazing, St. Michael's,

Matt, you also played junior hockey. What was your experience?

I played Junior B goalie for a team in Vancouver. This is a couple levels below the OHL. I never experienced or even saw the abuse that Carcillo did. The team I was on was well run. This sort of thing never happened but as a young player on the team — as a 17-year-old backup goalie — I did feel a power imbalance. The veterans controlled everything — the road trips, the rookie parties, who got what and who did what. There were several times where I felt threatened to do things that I was just not comfortable with at various rookie parties. 

Just like Carcillo, I didn't tell anyone — not parents, not coaches. I was fighting for playing time. I wanted to be on the ice. I wanted to try and make the next level. I didn't want to have a bad reputation attached to my name as a troublemaker. If a veteran player found out the situation could get worse. What Carcillo and his teammates and others who have experienced abuse in the hockey world are trying to do is change this hockey culture. This is not ok. They have created a big movement. We have seen that over the past week.

Carcillo won the Stanley Cup in 2013 and 2015 as a member of the Chicago Blackhawks. (Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Conrad Collaco is a CBC News producer for CBC Hamilton with extensive experience in online, television and radio news. Follow him on Twitter at @ConradCollaco, or email him at [email protected].