The Current

Report prescribes team-based approach to heal Canada's health-care system

It’s a common brag among Canadians that “we’ve got universal health care,” says Jane Philpott. But the former federal health minister says Canada is no longer worthy of the boast — and that it’s time to overhaul that system.

The idea that Canada is still a global leader in health-care is a myth, says former health minister

Simrin Sangha meets with her patient Jane Cassie at the Axis Primary Care Clinic in Surrey, B.C. Former health minister Jane Philpott says all levels of the health-care system need to be utilized for it to improve. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

Read Transcribed Audio

Canada's health-care system may not be the brag it once was, according to former health minister Dr. Jane Philpott. She says it needs a complete overhaul, starting with a team-based approach.

"We've had this kind of collective, national myth that we've got the best health-care system in the world, when in fact we pay more than most countries in the world per capita for our health system," Philpott told Matt Galloway on The Current.

"We rank well down the ranks in terms of the outcomes that Canadians are getting for that."

Philpott is co-author of a new report, Taking Back Health Care, from the Public Policy Forum that calls for an overhaul of Canada's health-care system. 

Former health minister Jane Philpott is coauthor of the report Taking Back Health Care. (Fred Chartrand/The Canadian Press)

The problem is widespread. According to a September poll by the Angus Reid Institute, six million Canadians don't have a family physician.

"I think the pandemic has put us into a realization of how broken things were, and now there's an urgency that is greater than ever to get things fixed," said Philpott. 

"Enough is enough. Let's fix this health-care system so that people will get what they need."

Philpott, who is now dean of the Faculty of Health Sciences at Queen's University in Kingston, Ont., says the decline of Canada's health-care system is due in part to fewer medical students entering family medicine, and a poorly designed system. 

Primary care home

Philpott says instead of each Canadian having a family doctor, she says everyone should have access to what she calls a "primary care home." 

"That doesn't necessarily mean you're going to see a family doctor, but you should be able to, on any given day, based on the urgency of your need, be able to get access to that primary care home," she said. 

That could mean being connected directly with a nurse practitioner, social worker, or pharmacist instead of a doctor. 

"We can actually do so in a way that's more affordable than what we're doing now. And people will be less frustrated and actually get their ailments treated in a much more timely fashion," said Philpott. 

Two doctors in hospital gowns and masks look over medical monitors.
Dr. Alika Lafontaine, right, says he has hope that the health-care system in Canada can be saved. (Dr. Brian Goldman/CBC)

It's something Dr. Alika Lafontaine says he's seen work in Alberta. Lafontaine is president of the Canadian Medical Association, and he says putting money into a team-based approach can not only improve health care, but also save money

"Team-based care is an opportunity for governments to fund more than just a doctor, more than just a nurse practitioner," said Lafontaine, a co-author of the recent report. 

He says in the current system, patients have to navigate a system with many separate, disconnected parts. A team-based approach connects all those pieces together in one place and requires fewer referrals. 

Philpott says such an approach has to be something everyone has access to, not just people who can afford to pay for privately run services. And it's important that approach also includes sharing data across provincial and territorial health-care systems. 

"Having a seamless access to data systems will improve patient care and definitely save money in the end," said Philpott.

Federal funding

Last week, federal Health Minister Jean-Yves Duclos said there's been a breakthrough in talks with provincial governments on the future of health-care funding. 

Man wearing suit and tie with serious expression on his face at press conference in front of row of Canadian flags.
Health Minister Jean-Yves Duclos listens to a question during a news conference, Jan. 20, 2023, in Ottawa. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

Lafontaine says that as politicians at the federal and provincial levels come together, it's important they listen to what people want. 

"Our health systems are a reflection of what we want and who we elect. And what this report is trying to do is help people know that if we call on governments to do things, and we're consistent and we're unified in doing it, governments will respond," said Lafontaine.

And if that happens, Lafontaine is hopeful. 

"If money gets invested in the right areas … we really could save the system. And I think it's really that refocus that needs to happen. And we do have I do have a lot of hope that things are going to change," said Lafontaine.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Philip Drost is a journalist with the CBC. You can reach him by email at [email protected].

Produced by Enza Uda.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Get the CBC Radio newsletter. We'll send you a weekly roundup of the best CBC Radio programming every Friday.

...

The next issue of Radio One newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.