Tom Cruise: Good or Bad?

Everyone off the fence! It's time for another one of q's patently polarizing Good or Bad debates. On trial this time: Mission Impossible star Tom Cruise.

Is Hollywood's top gun still a maverick? Or, at this point, is he just cruising? Guest host Jelena Adzic checks in with two passionate debaters: 

• Amy Nicholson is the author of a book-length appreciation of Cruise
• Alan Scherstuhl of the Village Voice begs to differ. Strongly differ.

Remember: there is no middle ground in our Good or Bad series! Cast your vote below. 

WEB EXTRA | Watch the clips we played on air today and tell us: does Tom Cruise hit the right note?